| Feature | SuperSU | Magisk |
|---|---|---|
| Source | Closed-source | Open-source |
| SafetyNet Compatibility | No | Yes |
| System Modification | Direct modification | Systemless modification |
| Module Support | Limited | Extensive (via Magisk Modules) |
| User Interface | Simple but basic | Advanced with more options |
Short Answer
Magisk is the preferred choice for modern rooting because of its systemless rooting method and extensive features, while SuperSU is a reliable but older option with system-level rooting.
Summary
This article compares Magisk and SuperSU, two popular Android rooting tools. Magisk uses a systemless rooting method, allowing for more flexibility and better compatibility with apps like Google Pay. SuperSU, on the other hand, modifies the system partition, making it less adaptable for modern requirements but still reliable for basic root needs. Both tools have their strengths and limitations, and the choice depends on the user’s needs and Android version.
Introduction
Rooting an Android device provides users with enhanced control, customization, and features. Over the years, Magisk and SuperSU have been the go-to tools for rooting. But which one is better in 2025? This article explores their differences, features, advantages, and drawbacks to help you decide which tool suits your needs.
What is Magisk?
Features of Magisk
- Systemless Rooting: Does not alter the system partition.
- Magisk Manager: A user-friendly app for managing root permissions and installing modules.
- SafetyNet Compatibility: Allows use of apps like Google Pay and Netflix.
- Modules: Extensive support for customizations via modules.
Advantages of Magisk
- Systemless rooting preserves the integrity of the system.
- Frequent updates keep it compatible with the latest Android versions.
- Bypasses SafetyNet checks for sensitive apps.
Disadvantages of Magisk
- Complex setup for beginners.
- Not all devices and firmware are supported.
What is SuperSU?
Features of SuperSU
- System-Level Rooting: Alters the system partition for root access.
- User Interface: Straightforward interface for managing root permissions.
- Compatibility: Works well on older Android versions.
Advantages of SuperSU
- Reliable and time-tested for basic rooting needs.
- Easy to use for beginners.
Disadvantages of SuperSU
- Alters the system partition, making it detectable by certain apps.
- No active development or support for recent Android versions.
Installation Process
Overview of the Installation Steps for Both Tools
SuperSU
- Requires a custom recovery tool, such as TWRP (Team Win Recovery Project).
- The SuperSU ZIP file is downloaded and flashed directly onto the device’s system partition.
- After flashing, the device reboots with root access enabled.
Magisk
- Similarly requires a custom recovery like TWRP for initial setup.
- Magisk ZIP is flashed onto the device, but it does not modify the system partition.
- Updates and management are handled easily through the Magisk Manager app, eliminating the need for repeated flashing in most cases.
- The systemless approach ensures smoother installation and compatibility with OTA updates.
Magisk vs SuperSU: Feature Comparison
Rooting Method
- Magisk: Systemless (non-intrusive to system files).
- SuperSU: System-level (modifies system files).
Compatibility
- Magisk: Works well with the latest Android versions and apps requiring SafetyNet checks.
- SuperSU: Limited compatibility with newer Android versions.
Customization
- Magisk: Offers extensive customization through modules.
- SuperSU: Minimal customization options.
App and SafetyNet Support
- Magisk: Passes SafetyNet checks, supporting apps like Google Pay.
- SuperSU: Often fails SafetyNet checks.
Current Trends (2025)
Recent Updates to Both Tools
- Magisk: Continues to receive frequent updates, ensuring compatibility with the latest Android versions. The Magisk Manager app now includes improved support for Android 12 and beyond, along with enhanced module management.
- SuperSU: Development has slowed significantly, with no major updates addressing the challenges posed by modern Android security measures. Its last updates focused on stability fixes for older devices.
Community Feedback on Performance and Reliability
- Magisk: Highly praised for its flexibility, modularity, and active development. Users appreciate the ability to use apps that rely on SafetyNet while maintaining root access.
- SuperSU: While still respected for its historical role in rooting, many users have moved away due to compatibility issues and the lack of updates. It remains a solid choice for older devices where Magisk may not be necessary
Use Cases
Choose Magisk If:
- You need to use apps like Google Pay or Netflix on a rooted device.
- You want modular customizations and frequent updates.
- You prefer a non-intrusive rooting method.
Choose SuperSU If:
- You are using an older Android device.
- You want a straightforward and reliable rooting solution.
- Compatibility with SafetyNet is not a concern.
Final Verdict
In 2025, Magisk stands out as the superior rooting tool due to its systemless approach, frequent updates, and compatibility with modern apps. While SuperSU remains a reliable option for older devices, its lack of recent updates and system-level rooting make it less suitable for newer Android versions. The choice ultimately depends on your specific requirements and device compatibility.
Frequently Asked Questions
1. Can I use Magisk and SuperSU together?
No, both tools use different rooting methods and cannot coexist on the same device.
2. Is rooting safe in 2025?
Rooting is safe if done carefully, but it voids warranties and may expose devices to security risks.
3. Which tool is easier for beginners?
SuperSU is simpler to use, but Magisk offers more features once you learn its setup.